EDUCATION

A Cary Teacher Is Baking on CBS Monday Night

A CARY TEACHER IS BAKING ON CBS MONDAY NIGHT: Kathy Cargill in her Cary kitchen. (Photo: Kathy Cargill)

On Monday night, a Cary teacher walks onto a CBS soundstage with a cake.

Kathy Cargill teaches fifth grade science here in Cary. She is one of 24 home bakers from across the country chosen for the Pillsbury Bake-Off Classic, a two-hour special that airs Monday at 8 PM on CBS and streams on Paramount+. Drew Barrymore hosts, and the judges are Christina Tosi, the chef and founder of Milk Bar, and New Orleans chef Dook Chase. The winner takes home $25,000, a KitchenAid equipment package, and the Golden Rolling Pin trophy.

The Bake-Off has been crowning home bakers since 1949, and this is the 54th edition. Cargill submitted her recipe earlier this year, went through a series of interviews, and got picked. She answered a few questions by email this week. The conversation has been lightly edited.

What did you bake for the competition?

“I made an Italian Rainbow Cake. It’s an almond cake with layers of raspberry preserves. Each layer of the cake is colored to represent the Italian flag. The whole cake is covered in chocolate ganache and a whipped cream frosting. My family is Italian, and I grew up in New Jersey. Whenever we had a big celebration, we would get treats from the Italian bakery. Rainbow cookies were one of my favorites. For this competition, I wanted to reimagine that cookie as a holiday celebration cake.”

How long have you lived in Cary, and what do you teach?

“My family moved to Cary from New Jersey in 2007, when I was in middle school. Although I left to attend college in Virginia and later spent a few years in Florida, Cary has always felt like home. I’m so thankful to have made my way back. I currently teach fifth grade science. I love fostering my students’ curiosity, helping them understand the natural world, and encouraging them to recognize their role in caring for it.”

How long have you been baking?

THE CARY REPORT
Enjoying this story?

Get the whole week in Cary in one free email, in your inbox every Wednesday at 7 AM. Council decisions, new businesses, events, and the stories everyone ends up talking about.

Free. No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.

“I grew up helping my mother and grandmother in the kitchen. During the holidays, we would bake Italian Christmas cookies and biscotti. In 2020, after the birth of my daughter and during the uncertainty of the pandemic, I discovered a renewed passion for baking. What started with sourdough bread quickly grew into cakes, pastries, cookies, pies, and laminated doughs. Since then, I have spent many hours teaching myself through books, baking shows, online resources, and plenty of trial and error. Now I bake with my daughter and continue the tradition of making Italian Christmas cookies with her.”

What was the experience like once you got there?

“The whole experience was so surreal and wonderful. Even though it’s a competition, it really didn’t feel like one. The other bakers were so friendly and encouraging. We were all rooting for each other. The set itself was so beautiful and decorated for the holidays. My parents, sisters, and New Jersey family were a part of the audience. Although I was nervous at times, seeing them up there in the stands and hearing them cheer me on kept me grounded and focused.”

What should Cary readers watch for on Monday night?

“The 24 bakers are divided into four groups of six, with each group competing in either the cookie, cake, pie, or biscuit round. The winner from each round advances to the final. There’s a lot of family stories and memories that will be shared. It’s definitely going to have that nostalgic, cozy holiday feel.”

And is there anything you are not allowed to share until it airs?

“I can’t reveal who advanced to the final round and who won the competition.”

So we wait until Monday, like everyone else. The Pillsbury Bake-Off Classic airs Monday, November 23 at 8 PM on CBS. Cargill competes in the cake round, and the four round winners meet in a finale where they build edible festive wreaths. Cary will be watching.

Front page